expert.gif (2096 bytes)

I: On the Reilly v. Hearst/Chronicle antitrust suit

II: On the Fang Family

III: On Clint Reilly, Plaintiff



================================
On the Reilly v. Hearst/Chronicle antitrust suit

"Based upon the information available to me about the agreement
between Hearst and Pan Asia (the Fangs), the Examiner will fold
its tent and be gone within three years."

- Thomas Clancy, former Senior Vice President, San Francisco Newspaper
Agency and former Vice President of the Chicago Tribune and Denver Post,
testifying in court, May 3, 2000


"The present subsidy by Hearst will not under any circumstances
be able to support the probability or even the possibility of a viable
paper which would be competitive with the Chronicle."

- Thamas G. Osborn of Santa Barbara, former Assistant Director of Circulation
for the Chicago Tribune, testifying in court, May 4, 2000


"I know of four cases where the Hearst Corporation killed a daily
newspaper, and one they left for dead."

- Robert Page, former owner/publisher of the Chicago Sun-Times and the Boston
Herald, former CEO of United Press International, testifying in court, May 3, 2000

"I believe Reilly's lawsuit is aimed at keeping two independent
voices alive."

- George Irish, president of Hearst Newspapers, quoted in SF Examiner,
March 18, 2000.

"I'd give anything to know what Hearst did to scare (Knight Ridder Chairman) Tony Ridder away so they could give it to somebody who looks to most eyes a lot less like a grown-up daily newspaper publisher."
Cynthia Gorney, associate professor at the Graduate School of Journalism at the University of California at Berkeley, quoted in SF Chronicle, March 18, 2000

"We ought to talk about how we can put together somebody, a group of people to buy The Examiner... Let Hearst have the Chronicle. Leave the Examiner, a civic treasure, for us."
Willie Brown, quoted in SF Examiner, January 9, 2000


"I would say that The San Francisco Examiner is not worth using as toilet paper."
Willie Brown, speaking in October 1997, quoted in SF Examiner, January
9, 2000



"You think I read the damn newspapers?"
Willie Brown, speaking in November 1997, quoted in SF Examiner, January
9, 2000



"I look forward to the day when there no longer is an Examiner."
Willie Brown, speaking in November 1995, quoted in SF Examiner, January
9, 2000

Top

===================

On the Fang Family

"If (Ted Fang) runs the Examiner in any fashion similar to how he's run
the San Francisco Independent, we can look forward to unwarranted
smears, use of a major paper for what appears to be purely political
purposes, and a really, really skewed version of reality on a daily
basis. I can only call it a journalistic horror story."

John Mecklin, editor and news columnist at the SF Weekly, quoted in SF
Chronicle, March 18, 2000


"As court documents and sworn witness testimony have shown, the Fangs
engaged in acts so duplicitous and brazenly unethical that their case
should be submitted for special entry into the Journalism Hall of
Shame."

Ken Garcia, columnist, SF Chronicle, May 6, 2000


"If you're looking for them (the Fangs) to lead the way for civil
rights, they won't. They like to have control, you know, so politicians
will kowtow to them."

Rose Pak of the Chinese Chamber of Commerce and a former reporter for
the San Francisco Chronicle, quoted in SF Examiner, March 18, 2000



"Some of the things they publish in the Independent are political hit
pieces... I am concerned about how they will run The Examiner. I hope
they don't bring that type of journalism to The Examiner."

Arnold Chin, president of the San Francisco Board of Appeals and former
president of the Chinese Chamber of Commerce, quoted in SF Examiner,
March 18, 2000



"The Independent used to be a decent newspaper, (but) all they (the
Fangs) do is pump out filth in every election. Many see them as
self-serving and vengeful.''

Barbara Meskunas, former president of the Housing Authority Commission
and a former Fang employee at the Independent, quoted in SF Chronicle,
March 18, 2000



"[Ted Fang's Independent has] relinquished, to a great extent, its role
of balanced objective journalism in favor of campaign rhetoric and
machine propaganda [and should] cease acting as a mouthpiece for any
political machine."

Official Resolution passed by the Harvey Milk Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual,
Transgender Democratic Club, quoted in SF Examiner, September 30, 1999



"I watch the Independent like it's Pravda."
San Francisco Public Defender Jeff Brown, quoted in SF Examiner,
September 30, 1999

Top

===================

On Clint Reilly, Plaintiff

"Reilly may or may not win the lawsuit he has filed to block the sale.
He may or may not prove his charge that the sale is a sham. But he's
already done the city - and American journalism - a great favor by
forcing into the public eye the inner secrets of one of the most
secretive corporate institutions in the city, the daily newspapers."

- Tim Redmond, Executive Editor, SF Bay Guardian, May 3, 2000

"Clint Reilly's antitrust suit to block the sale of The Chronicle may
or may not prevail in the court of law -- but in the court of public
opinion, the guy is definitely cleaning everyone's clock."

- Phil Matier and Andrew Ross, San Francisco Chronicle reporters,
quoted in San Francisco Chronicle, May 5, 2000


"I'm not convinced he [Clint Reilly] has much of an antitrust case, but
I agree he's done San Francisco a great service in getting all this
into the open."

- Vlae Kershner, News Director, SFGate.com, May 05, 2000

"I believe Reilly's lawsuit is aimed at keeping two independent voices
alive."

- George Irish, president of Hearst Newspapers, quoted in SF
Examiner, March 18, 2000.

Top